The only thing I didnt like about the review (after watching it a few times) was the reviewer was trying to compare it to San Andreas too much (the map, the gameplay, etc).. he's forgetting its an entirely new game, and the first of its kind.. EVER! So you cant compare it to anything else cause there has never been anything like this.
And he says the textures are dull and boring.. but they were designed like that for a purpose. It's all in the atmosphere that the game gives off.. if it was all colourful and pretty then it woulnt (in my opinion anyway) be as appealing as it is.
I reckon it would have scored a lot higher then 8 if the reviewer was considering this.