I and everyone else here defiantly want a Bully 2 buddy. And if we could make it happen we sure would. We've all played Bully a ton. I personally ain't bored of it yet, and don't think I will be. But it's always nice to have new content if it's a new game or DLC. The game it's self didn't sell that well, at least 1.5 million. And I think that's with the PS2, 360, Wii, and PC combined. Imo though that would warrant enough for another game. The thing is though, I don't think Rockstar knows how much this game is loved.
As for new games like Red Dead Redemption, LA Noire, or even Agent. It's nice to have new IP's in the market, a lot of sequels are getting pushed out at the moment. Will there be a Bully 2? No one can say for sure until it is announced. And even then, you can't until it actually hit's stores. It defiantly has been a long time for fans, especially if they have been there since the beginning.
You look at GTA, each squeal tops the last. GTA IV had so much stuff stuffed into it, it was incredible. Red Dead Revolver was an ok game. Red Dead Redemption blew people away with how much better it was. You look at Bully, it's an incredible game already as it is. You know with out a doubt Rockstar will top themselves with the next one. But Bully had got to be harder to make ideas for, it's one of the most unique games ever made.
Why is that? Look at the setting and characters. No one has ever tried to pull that off. And mark my words, no one would ever be able to do it either. Sorry for the long read.