PS2 VS PC Graphics

[DaBOSS54320]

So, obviously the PC version (or well Scholarship Edition in general) came out after the original PS2 version. There was dramatic graphical changes as it runs on an entirely different engine. In some aspects... the PC does look better, but at the same time I personally still really like the PS2's look. It looks a bit more realistic to me in a way, except for the shitty shadows.
I think the PS2 version really thrives in interiors, but the PC version probably takes the win when outside.

Here's some screenshots I took on both PS2 and PC in similar situations so you can compare. Here's some details about the screenshots:
The PC screenshots I took running max settings of the regular patched version of the game. No graphic mods or world.img mods at all.
The PS2 screenshots I took on PCSX2, I was running in software mode. I had 6x native resolution and some anti aliasing.
If you can't tell which is PC and which is PS2, just look for the clock. When I took the screenshots I didn't unlock the clock yet so the PS2 screenshots lack a clock.

[Mick3Mouse]

PC

[DaBOSS54320]

I think overall PC is probably better but idk something to ps2 just looks really different but good to me.

[BloodChuckZ]

I'm used to the PS2 look, so anything else just looks weird.

[Owais Qadri]

Pc is definitely better.

[Unknownsoldier]

Honestly, the PS2 graphics are more relaxing to the eye, and just a bit more dull. But the PC graphics are far more colorful, sharper, and higher contrasted than the PS2. So I'd have to go with PC.

[Owais Qadri]

Pc would be easier to play on.

[SWEGTA]

PC.
PS2 has a certain feel to it, but PC is way superior.

[Owais Qadri]

Ps2 version is good ps2 is the used to one.

[DahCobra33]

I actually like both and I don't think I can compare them that way...I mean,there ain't a better one IMO...But ps2 one had awful shadowing,and PC edition had that stupid dome.

[Owais Qadri]

Pc edition has better graphics.

[DahCobra33]

PS2 limits.

[Owais Qadri]

What about ps3 and x box

[Bigfoot]

I've got the PS2 and Wii versions.  They both look rather similar (some minor improvements on the Wii version graphically), but the PS2 game has vastly superior audio.  The Wii's dialogue sounds like it was simply recorded via microphone off a TV set.

[Hayley]

I prefer the PS2's dark, gloomy, "this place really is crappy" look. It's very fitting. Playing the xbox/pc version for the first time was really strange with how sunny everything looked. Graphics mean nothing to me.