I've found that a lot of the ones who claim RDR is better than Bully use the argument that the graphics are better. Sure, I don't want to play with an ugly and old game but I'd much rather be on a game with mediocre graphics and high re-playability than a game with awesome graphics and no re-playability. Look at the GTA series for example, while I loved GTA 3, Vice City and San Andreas for the fact that I could play them over and over again — GTA 4 and GTA 5 were one time plays for me. I messed around in free roam on both of those titles and then finally beat the story and never played 'em again.