Great Work as always!
I think you are really good at creating creepy and dark stuff
and There's actually a lot of creepy place in Bully, and one of it is the asylum, the church maybe you can use it & combine it with your Gary Werewolf skin to make a creepy machinima
and there lots of creepy place too, the apartment, the school basement, The warehouse, etc
or Maybe make a detective movie that has a trill in it
I got some good movie reference, like the "Shutter Island" or "Se7en"
Well, you don't really to need to follow all the plot from the movie,
But I think you just can use the core of the story and use it as the base for your machinima and connect it with Bully World, for eg.
"Shutter Island" = a detective that go the asylum to find a missing patient
or "Se7en" = a detective that try to solve & catch the se7en sin serial killer
Just like how you create your Jeff The Killer Series
Thanks